CO129-324 - Governor Nathan - 1904 [10-12] — Page 532

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

C.O. 2396

Report by Mr. Foalton.

RECO

Prot 25 JAN 05

531

Unfortunately I cannot claim to have any critical knowledge of that difficult branch of engineering which deals with the control and regulation of rivers. I must therefore be excused from giving a formal opinion in this respect.

So far as I can judge, Captain Tyler's proposals are such that the most experienced engineer in this particular line would, I should think, hesitate to predict the result of a complete removal of the barriers. He would rather proceed warily with their removal, and be guided by results. It seems to be probable that a partial removal will be found to be efficient, and that if money is then available it will best be exercised in dealing with the natural waterways.

I desire to be permitted to thank His Excellency for the privilege of seeing Captain Tyler's instructive report, and to express regret for my inability to be serviceable on this occasion.

18-11-04.

Edit History

2026-06-01 22:21:01 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
C.O. 2396 Report by Mr. Foalton. RECO Prot 25 JAN 05 531 Unfortunately I cannot claim to have any critical knowledge of that difficult branch of engineering which deals with the control and regulation of rivers. I must therefore be excused from giving a formal opinion in this respect. So far as I can judge, Captain Tyler's proposals are such that the most experienced engineer in this particular line would, I should think, hesitate to predict the result of a complete removal of the barriers. He would rather proceed warily with their removal, and be guided by results. It seems to be probable that a partial removal will be found to be efficient, and that if money is then available it will best be exercised in dealing with the natural waterways. I desire to be permitted to thank His Excellency for the privilege of seeing Captain Tyler's instructive report, and to express regret for my inability to be serviceable on this occasion. 18-11-04.
Baseline (Original)
C.O. 2396 Report by Mr. Foalton. RECO Prot 25 JAN 05 531 Unfortunately I cannot clair to have any crectical non- eize of that Hifficult/branch of engineerine which deals with the control eni regulation of rivers. I must therefore be leave to be excised from giving a formal opinion in this restep. So far as 1 can liige, Captain Tyler's crocosals are so in). the most experienced engineer in unis particular line wouli, 1 should think, hesitate to predict the result of a complete removal of the barriers. He would rather oppose) wariiv with their removal, an be niej by resuite. It seems to be probable that a rertial Peroval will be tomi to be efficient, and that it poney is then evalleris it will best be excesiei in jealing with the natural wat Piers. I jesire to be berritter to thank His excelionov for the brivilege of seeing Cyutain Ivier's instructive recort, and to ex- press regret for my tallite to be serviceable on this occasion. 33. J. §. 5. 18-11-04.
2026-06-01 22:21:01 · Baseline
View content

C.O.

2396

Report by Mr. Foalton.

RECO

Prot 25 JAN 05

531

Unfortunately I cannot clair to have any crectical non-

eize of that Hifficult/branch of engineerine which deals with the

control eni regulation of rivers. I must therefore be leave to be excised from giving a formal opinion in this restep.

So far as 1 can liige, Captain Tyler's crocosals are so in). the most experienced engineer in unis particular line wouli, 1 should think, hesitate to predict the result of a complete removal of the barriers. He would rather oppose) wariiv with their removal,

an be niej by resuite. It seems to be probable that a rertial

Peroval will be tomi to be efficient, and that it poney is then evalleris it will best be excesiei in jealing with the natural wat

Piers.

I jesire to be berritter to thank His excelionov for the brivilege of seeing Cyutain Ivier's instructive recort, and to ex- press regret for my tallite to be serviceable on this occasion.

33. J. §. 5.

18-11-04.

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.